| | Player
of the Year | Coach of the Year |
1988 | | John Courtright
- Marion Harding | Larry Merchant - Marion Harding |
1989 | | Tim Schwamberger
- Madison | Dick Windbigler - Malabar |
1990 | | Roger
Touby - Madison | Tim Rupert - Madison |
1991 | | Touby
McMillen - Madison | Larry Merchant - Marion Harding |
1992 | | Robert Holmes
- Marion Harding | Jeff Burnett - Ashland |
1993 | | J.
J. Lang - Ashland | Jeff Burnett - Ashland & Rob Peterson -
Madison |
1994 | | Chris
Wallace - Marion Harding | Rob Peterson - Madison |
1995 | | Orlando Rogers
- Marion Harding | Larry Merchant - Marion Harding |
1996 | | Steve Thurber
- Madison | Jeff Burnett - Ashland |
1997 | | J.
P. Felty - Marion Harding | Larry Merchant - MH. & Rob Peterson
- Madison |
1998 | | Daniel
Lunsford - Madison | Jeff Burnett - Ashland |
1999 | | Daniel
Lunsford - Madison | Doug Rickert - Madison |
2000 | | Daniel
Lunsford - Madison | Doug Rickert - Madison |
2001 | | Jim
Williams - Madison | Doug Rickert - Madison |
2002 | | Kurt
Eichorn - Lexington | Jeff Strickler - Lexington |
2003 | | Rory Meister - Madison | Doug
Rickert - Madison |